Digital Evidence Before UAE Courts: Admissibility of WhatsApp Messages, Emails & Electronic Records

With the push into the newly established post-modern digital age, all facets of life have seen tremendous strides into innovation to streamline and prioritize efficiency and time consumption; to accompany this initiative, both laws and the institutions that dispense such law must adapt to new forms of crime that would otherwise fall between the lines of archaic and outdated statutes. The UAE has, in response, adopted a nationwide drive to implement advanced technologies into every facet of daily life to secure societal safety and ensure civil cohesion and stability, with implementation most importantly being seen in their Court system and new laws. With that in mind, a large component of how individuals communicate personally and, in a business, capacity is through that of electronic means, such as WhatsApp, Emails, Text Messages, and other forms of electronic documentation, so this therefore demands new methods of regulation, and updated legal framework to facilitate the admissibility and review of evidence that would come in the form of electronic messages and documentation.

The Statutory pillar governing and regulating the legality and admission of electronic evidence in the UAE is Federal Decree-Law No. 46 of 2021 on Electronic Transactions and Trust Services. Its creation was to directly address and establish legitimacy and transparency over how electronic transactions, signatures, documents, document retention, and service provider requirements are handled in Court, including the admission and validity of evidence and how to treat with that evidence. Additionally, Federal Decree-Law No. 35 of 2022 Promulgating the Law of Evidence in Civil and Commercial Transactions further authorizes the usage of electronic and digital evidence in Court with a dedicated chapter; due to this, both laws often overlap in affirming that electronic evidence bares the same legal weight in Court as written evidence. It is, however, important to note that these two laws are predominantly applicable when concerning cases heard in UAE civil and commercial courts, with cases handled in criminal courts relying on separate statutes. Within the wording of Federal Decree-Law No. 46, it is evident that the statute establishes an intrinsic shift in attitude by the UAE Courts in their approach towards digital proof and electronic documentation by verifying that such electronic documents are treated with the same weight and enforceability as Courts would regard with written physical documentation. Furthermore, Article 5 of the Federal Decree clarifies further that the legal enforceability of data enclosed in electronic documents remains unimpaired, provided the documentation can be accessed by way of the originator’s information system, and that the electronic document plainly indicates how said access can be obtained.

Following this, Federal Decree-Law No. 35 of 2022, specifically Articles 60-64, governs the procedural requirements placed on electronic documentation for successful admittance as evidence in Court. Firstly, the evidence must be provided in its original electronic format or any alternative electronic means; In this instance The Court reserves the right to request a physically written version of the evidence if it is possible to make such an adaptation. Additionally, if a party refuses, without providing a valid reason, to provide electronic evidence that is otherwise compulsory by The Courts to validate its authenticity, they forfeit their right to rely on it, or it may even be used against them. Furthermore, if the legal validity of electronic evidence cannot be authenticated for reasons outside both party’s influence or control, then The Court has the authority to assess its probative value based upon the cases circumstances. Lastly, copies or extracts of both electronic evidence and electronic payment details hold the same legal significance and weight as the originals, given they remain identical to the original electronic record. All of this being noted, UAE Judges do retain discretion, and digital evidence provided alone is commonly not sufficient to sway The Courts, it needs to be supported by confessions, witnesses, and further expert opinions.

Moreover, Courts impose further standards for the admission of electronic evidence. Due to the national language being Arabic, it is mandatory for all electronic messages to be transcribed and/or printed and translated into Arabic by a UAE Ministry of Justice-certified translator. You must also prove that the messages were sent by and received by the respected parties, where the original data, such as the chat history, should be retained. If messaging chats, such as WhatsApp chats are admitted, then the messages must be presented from the original device on which they were received; forwarded or manipulated data may be rejected by The Courts. Digital forensics additionally hold merit, as if the opposing party challenges the authenticity of the electronic evidence, The Court or public prosecutor will order a forensic IT examination of the devices submitted, to validate the authenticity of the data. Finally, the question of legal acquisition is posed; in this instance, the electronic evidence must be obtained legally, as data gathered through illegal hacking or breaches of UAE privacy laws is inadmissible, and may result in further criminal penalties.

The standards for admittance of evidence when arbitration is concerned, such as the DIAC, alter slightly from what is desired by UAE national courts. Arbitral tribunals typically adhere to international practices, such as the IBA Rules on the Taking of Evidence in International Arbitration. Digital evidence must be organized through hyperlinked indices and securely exchanged by way of e-discovery platforms.

Expanding upon the appearance and admittance of digital messages possessing the same legal weight as that of verbal and physically written communication, WhatsApp communication has seen strong recognition from UAE Courts in recent years, and has gone as far as being recognized as legally binding contracts. The Dubai Court of Cassation has recently made a strong judgement, Cassation No. 468 2024 Civil, that delivers a detailed analysis of the prerequisites of validity for electronic evidence. As detailed in this case, both parties exchanged communication on WhatsApp regarding a USD 400,000 loan, without the pre-establishment or discussion of a formal contract, or any formal documentation. Despite this, however, the court ruled in the favor that this exchange between individuals on WhatsApp constituted a valid, legally binding contractual agreement, regarding it as tantamount to a physically signed contract. The decision by The Dubai Court of Cassation is a substantial one, as it emphasizes the fact that simple electronic messages discussing business, irrespective of whether any form or copy of a contract is exchanged, can nevertheless demonstrate and prove the validity of a contractual agreement that, in the eyes of the court, stands on an equal playing field with that of substantial provided evidence of physical signatures by multiple parties.

This judgement accentuates that the form of communication, whether that be email, WhatsApp, or alternative electronic messaging means, must meet with the prerequisites detailed in Federal Decree-Law No. 35 2022 regarding evidence. One key feature of this is the necessity to verify the identity of the individual bound by the mutual agreement, regarding this case, the borrower did not deny the validity of the messages exchanged on WhatsApp with the lender, but instead disputed the existence of a loan between them. Despite this, however, because the borrower acknowledged that messages were exchanged between them, the court concluded that the identity of the sender was satisfactorily confirmed. This was achieved because in the UAE, mobile numbers can be used to handle a multitude of matters and business, including notifying someone of legal proceedings, as well as performing government transactions and applications. It is then relatively easy for UAE Courts to establish that certain mobile numbers belong to certain individuals, almost as a form of personal identity.

A further instance of UAE Courts adaptation to the use of electronic documents is demonstrated in Cassation No. 451 2021. In this instance, the court upheld the legal status of a divorce originating from a four-word WhatsApp message declaring for it; notwithstanding the husband’s protests, stating that the WhatsApp declaration was impulsive and to not be taken as a serious intention to divorce, the court ruled that the message did meet the legally valid requirements needed to initiate a formal divorce.

These legal precedents and ground-breaking case studies highlight a strong desire of initiative and innovation by the UAE Courts to step-up-to and remain in the forefront of cutting-edge legal decisions and adaptation. As the world evolves to integrate electronic mediums into everyday life, it stands to reason that laws and regulations must meet that halfway. As seen in Federal Decree-Law No. 46 2021 and No. 35 2022, electronic evidence, in the eyes of the courts, can hold just as much legal merit as that of physical evidence, but does require a higher standard of evidential validation.